
Photo: “Pot” by RichardBH, CC BY 2.0. Resized and converted to WebP.
Cowboy Coffee
Boiled-pot coffee, done right, with no gritty cup
The Trail Story
Coffee was the one thing a cattle crew would not do without. It was brewed strong in a big pot, often before dawn, and kept hot all day. Early on, many outfits roasted and ground green beans themselves. Later, pre-roasted coffee sold in packages became popular, and Arbuckles' is the brand most often remembered in cowboy lore.
The method was simple: boil water, throw in the grounds, let it steep and settle. Cooks used a splash of cold water or a crushed eggshell to sink the grounds. Our modern version keeps the method but takes the pot off the boil, so the brew is bold rather than bitter.
- Time
- 2 min prep · 10 min cook
- Serves
- 4 · 3 ingredients
- Difficulty
- Easy
- Heat
- Campfire or stovetop kettle/pot
Ingredients
4 mugs (about 8 oz each)
Equipment
- Pot or kettle
- Thermometer (optional)
Steps
Step 1: Bring 4 cups of water to a boil, then take it off the heat for 30 seconds (to about 200°F).
Step 2: Stir in the coffee and the pinch of salt.
Step 3: Cover and steep 2 minutes. Stir once, then steep 2 minutes more.
Step 4: Sprinkle the ¼ cup cold water over the surface to sink the grounds and wait 1 minute.
Step 5: Pour slowly into mugs, leaving the last bit and the grounds in the pot.
Cookie's Tips
- Grind coarse, like kosher salt. Fine grounds won't settle and make the cup muddy.
- Boiling the coffee itself pulls out bitterness, which is why we take the water off the boil first.
- A clean eggshell works surprisingly well to clarify, and it's a fun piece of history to try.
Substitutions
- A French press for the pot
- Same coarse grind, 4-minute steep, then press.
- Chicory blended 1:3 with coffee for all-coffee
- A stretch-the-coffee trick from the 1800s.